$1.67 billion at stake in benefits typo lawsuit
These days a pro-employer courtroom verdict is about as common as a Bigfoot sighting. That’s why what happened in this case is good news for companies everywhere.
A federal appeals court recently sided with Verizon Communications, Inc. in a case involving their retirement plan language.
Here’s what happened. When the company was moving workers from one pension plan to another, it accidentally included a multiplier tied to workers’ ages and years of service twice.
This mistake actually increased the starting balances for thousands of workers under the new plan and, in many cases, nearly tripled them.
However, when the company caught the mistake, several employees (with Cynthia Young as the lead plaintiff) cried foul. They sued, claiming the company should be bound by language in the plan.
The court disagreed, and Judge John Daniel Tinder wrote, “People make mistakes. Even administrators of ERISA plans.”
The company is allowed to fix the mistake, which could have cost it $1.67 billion.
Cite: Cynthia Young v. Verizon’s Bell Atlantic Cash Balance Plan
- Share on
Free Training & Resources
White Papers
Provided by Anaplan
White Papers
Provided by UJET
White Papers
Provided by Anaplan
Further Reading
With benefits costs climbing and new laws like SECURE 2.0 adding complexity, viewing employee benefits as a simple fixed cost is an outdate...
Employees may not understand lifestyle spending accounts (LSAs) as well as you think. That can lead to questions or just confusion. Thi...
In April, Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders signed legislation making it illegal for Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) to own or oper...
A new proposed rule from the Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration outlines how 401(k) fiduciaries must assess ...
On Aug. 7, 2025, President Trump signed an executive order expanding 401(k) plans’ ability to include alternative investments – such as...
While the IRS can assess penalties under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), it can’t issue the certifications required beforehand, a court ha...
