Hiring a bad employee can cost more than you’d think
Nobody wants to make a bad hire. But you may be surprised by just how much a single mistake can cost.
It turns out, there are six factors that contribute to the total cost of hiring a bad employee, according to Inc.com:
- hiring costs
- total compensation
- cost of maintaining the employee
- disruption costs
- severance, and
- any money lost on mistakes and missed opportunities.
If you add up the total spent on each factor for an under-performing employee who’s been let go, you can estimate how much money your company could have saved by hiring someone better.
The formula works across industries and can be applied to any level candidate.
For example, according to the formula, a poorly performing mid-level manager with an annual salary of $62,000 can wind up costing the company around $800,000 if he’s/she’s let go after two and a half years.
The costs drag on
Disappointing employees can also continue to cost you money after they’ve left the company. Each time an employee is fired, a position opens up. And that means your hiring committee will have to take time away from their day-to-day responsibilities to conduct recruitment, interview and track down references. It can lead to a lot time lost.
And when they find a good replacement, there’s still money to be spent on the new employee’s onboarding. U.S. organizations spent $156.2 billion on employee learning and development last year, according to the American Society for Training and Development’s 2012 State of the Industry Report.
The best way to avoid all these losses is to shore up your hiring process. For example, if you’re experiencing heightened turnover, try reviewing the interviews of under-performing employees to look for ways your company can improve its vetting process.
Free Training & Resources
White Papers
Provided by UJET
White Papers
Provided by Anaplan
Further Reading
Beware of auto pilot when issuing expense reimbursement checks to employees. Some, or all, of the money may technically be wages instead. ...
Most employers give out annual pay raises, according to a new survey. However, the increase isn’t enough to keep up with inflation. Th...
A physical therapy and rehabilitation clinic in Hawaii recently learned an expensive lesson about overtime compliance after a federal inves...
Some payroll staffers may assume that complying with IRS regulations is enough to keep their companies out of trouble. That’s not ...
IRS has given employers two extra years to implement a Secure 2.0 Act provision that’s bringing tax changes for certain retirement pl...
On July 4, 2025, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act became law, with numerous tax implications for employers as well as employees. HR 1 exte...