5 illegal screening questions everybody asks
How many of these have you asked when searching for just the right staff for Finance?
It’s tough enough to find and land the perfect person for your finance department. But the headaches that resume scouring cause are nothing compared to the headache of being sued for discrimination.
Here are five questions to strike from your to-ask list, pronto:
- “What year did you graduate?” Easy to fall into — a candidate went to the same high school you did. Naturally you’re curious. But you just backed yourself into the age question. You know you can never come out and say “How old are you?” or “Really, you have grandchildren?” but anything that would lead the interviewee to disclose that number on his or her driver’s license is a potential minefield.
- “Are you married?” Again, may sound like pleasant conversation. But it’s a slippery slope. Say you’re interviewing a 20-something woman. That innocuous question can lead to asking about starting a family … and claims of pregnancy discrimination. Steer clear.
- “How far would your commute be?” You can’t pick and choose based on who’s “geographically desirable.” If anything, ask whether an 8 am workday start is doable.
- “Are you comfortable supervising men/women?” A legitimate concern? Sure. But you’d have better luck asking about the teams this person has supervised in the past to get an inkling how they fare telling the opposite sex what to do.
- “Do you smoke?” Even if your company is taking a hard line against smokers — and many are — you probably shouldn’t ask this directly. You can ask whether the candidate has ever been disciplined for violating company anti-tobacco policies.
Free Training & Resources
White Papers
Provided by Anaplan
Further Reading
Heads up: Companies can avoid criminal prosecution and million-dollar payouts for serious violations and mistakes by taking advantage of th...
Back in 2013, the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) accused hedge fund manager George Jarkesy of defrauding two investors. Unlike ...
Employers are facing higher penalty amounts in 2025 for violations of several employment laws, including the Family and Medical Leave Act (...
In April 2025, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) released an updated version of Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verificati...
California’s latest misclassification penalty provides a costly reminder: Once contractor oversight starts resembling employee management...
It’s a wildly astronomical number, and we’re not trying to scare anyone – but a recent case from New Jersey shows that employee miscl...